The JSA has a long-standing legacy, but letting them coexist with Superman and the Justice League could undermine both generations of heroes.
The Justice Society of America is the best team of Golden Age DC heroes, but they are rarely DC Comics’ top dogs. That role, of course, goes to Superman, who is supposed to be the main icon in both the DC Universe and in real life. It showed me if there was a problem.
Putting the Justice Society in the same world as Superman robs them of both their due influence and prestige.It was one of several missteps made by the creators of Crisis of infinitySuperman, in fact, doesn’t quite fit into the world where the JSA was the first superhero team.
Superman’s debut won’t be as impactful if the JSA already exists
the driving force of Crisis of infinity DC was meant to get rid of some alternate Earths and realities. So Justice Society of America existed during the World War II era of this new reality, and Superman didn’t debut until modern times. Considering it’s supposed to be a superhero, it did a great deal of damage to Man of Steel’s impact.
If the JSA were already there, the idea of a flying man with incredible power would be less impressive. Superman’s debut is therefore less in the eyes of the public, who logically compare him to heroes from the star-studded past of “All-American.” John Byrne never addressed this when he rebooted Superman.crisis It was continuous. The social change that Superman’s presence would cause is highly questionable, as heroes such as the JSA and Wonder Woman were already active in the past.
As mentioned above, the JSA existed long before Superman was born.crisis And DC Rebirth continuity. Nonetheless, Superman’s arrival is the only one that has been truly honored within the DC Universe, and the JSA are rarely mentioned outside of their own books and stories. It is the maximum result to try to put on the earth. If the JSA were meant to keep its classic Golden Age premise, the team and their history would quickly become an afterthought compared to the far more popular Superman. The same goes for Justice League, featuring the famous Barry Allen and Hal Jordan versions.
The Justice Society ultimately works best in a world where Superman and the Justice League don’t exist, or at least exist on another Earth. This way, Superman could debut alongside the JSA and never outshine them. DC Comics is now reviving the JSA in a big way, further exploring its Golden Age characters.But at the same time, its main focus remains on characters like Superman and Batman. It remains to be seen how big the Justice Society will grow in the meantime.
